Challenging a Will: Your Complete Guide

Challenging a will is a serious legal action that questions the validity or fairness of a deceased person’s final wishes. This process often occurs during probate, but it can happen after probate as well. If you believe something went wrong in the drafting or execution of a will, you may have grounds to challenge it.

Let’s explore when, why, and how to take action when you suspect a will should be contested. We’ll also look at common reasons, legal procedures, examples, and how to protect your own will from being challenged.

What Does Challenging a Will Mean?

Challenging a will means disputing its legal validity in court. You might believe the will was created under suspicious conditions or doesn’t represent the true intentions of the deceased. This challenge can delay or even change the distribution of assets in an estate.

The probate process verifies a will and handles the distribution of a person’s estate. However, when someone raises concerns about the will, a court may need to investigate before any property can be passed on to heirs.

---

Who Can Challenge a Will?

Only people with legal standing may challenge a will. That means you must be directly affected by the outcome of the estate. You may have standing if:

• You were a beneficiary in a prior will.
• You are named in the current will.
• You would inherit under state intestacy laws if no will existed.
• You believe a newer valid will exists.

If you’re unsure about your standing, consult a probate attorney before moving forward.

Legal Grounds for Challenging a Will

You cannot challenge a will just because you are unhappy with it. You must have valid legal grounds. The most common reasons include:

1. Lack of Testamentary Capacity

The person writing the will (the testator) must understand:

• • What a will is and what it does.
  • The extent of their property.
  • Who they are leaving property to.

If the testator suffered from dementia, delusions, or severe illness at the time the will was made, you may have grounds to challenge it.

2. Undue Influence

Undue influence happens when someone pressures or manipulates the testator into changing their will. This often involves:

• • Caregivers isolating the testator.
  • New spouses or friends suddenly inheriting everything.
  • The will dramatically changing from a previous version.

If someone close to the testator benefited unfairly, it’s worth investigating.

3. Fraud or Forgery

If the will was forged or the testator was tricked into signing it, that’s fraud. For instance, someone might have slipped a will in front of the testator and claimed it was another document. Forged signatures also fall into this category.

4. Improper Execution

Wills must meet legal requirements in the state where the testator lived. That often includes:

• • Signed by the testator.
  • Signed by two or more disinterested witnesses.
  • Sometimes notarized.

If these steps weren’t followed, the will might be declared invalid.

5. Existence of a More Recent Will

If a newer, legally valid will comes to light, the older will being used can be contested. Courts typically honor the most recent valid version.

How to Challenge a Will in 5 Steps

Step 1: Talk to a Probate Attorney

Will contests are complex. Start by speaking with an estate or probate attorney. They can help determine if you have a valid claim and guide you through the process.

Step 2: Know Your State’s Deadline

Each state sets a deadline to contest a will, usually counted from:

• • The date of the testator’s death.
  • The date the will was filed in probate court.

This period may be 30 days, 6 months, or 2 years, depending on the state. Missing the deadline means losing your right to challenge.

Step 3: File a Petition to Contest the Will

To begin the legal process, file a petition in probate court. This formally notifies the court and other heirs that you are contesting the will. You’ll need to:

• • Identify yourself and your relationship to the deceased.
  • State your grounds for challenging the will.
  • Present supporting documentation.

Each state has its own filing requirements, so check with the probate office or use an attorney.

Step 4: Gather Your Evidence

Your case must be supported with strong evidence. This might include:

• • Earlier versions of the will.
  • Medical records showing lack of capacity.
  • Testimonies from friends or professionals.
  • Proof of fraud or suspicious changes.

You may also need expert witnesses such as doctors or handwriting analysts.

Step 5: Go to Mediation or Court

Your case may go to mediation or a full trial.

• • Mediation allows both parties to settle the matter with the help of a neutral third party.
  • Court hearings involve discovery, depositions, and final judgments from a probate judge.

If you settle out of court, the estate may be divided according to the agreement. If not, the judge will determine the will’s validity.

Examples of Challenging a Will

Example 1: Mental Capacity in Question

An elderly man with early Alzheimer’s disease signs a new will naming his home care worker as the main beneficiary. His daughter, the previous beneficiary, challenges the will on the basis of mental incapacity. She presents medical records and letters from doctors supporting her case.

Example 2: Last-Minute Will Changes

A woman makes a new will days before her sudden death, leaving everything to a new spouse and disinheriting her adult children. The children challenge the will, claiming undue influence and improper witness signatures. The court may investigate and possibly reinstate an earlier will.

Contesting a Will After Probate

Can you challenge a will after it has been accepted by the court? Yes, but timing is key.

You must act quickly after probate. Most states allow a limited time—such as 6 months—to contest. The sooner you act, the better.

Post-probate contests require:

• Filing a legal petition.
• Proving your standing.
• Demonstrating grounds for contest.

The court will review the petition, schedule a hearing, and consider all evidence. If successful, the court may revoke the will and apply a prior one—or apply intestacy laws.

How Much Does It Cost to Challenge a Will?

Costs vary by location and case complexity. They can include:

• Attorney’s hourly fees ($250–$750/hour).
• Court filing fees.
• Expert witness fees (doctors, handwriting analysts).
• Document retrieval and service costs.

In total, challenging a will can cost several thousand to tens of thousands of dollars. It’s important to weigh these costs before proceeding.

How Often Are Will Challenges Successful?

Successful challenges are rare. Courts presume wills are valid. The burden of proof lies entirely on the person contesting the will.

However, success is more likely when:

• There is clear evidence of incapacity or undue influence.
• Witnesses support your claim.
• The will contradicts earlier versions without explanation.

What Happens If You Win?

If you successfully challenge a will, several things could happen:

• A previous version of the will is reinstated.
• The estate is distributed under intestacy laws.
• A settlement agreement is reached between parties.

Keep in mind, winning a will contest can significantly alter how assets are distributed. It may also protect rightful heirs and honor the true intentions of the deceased.

Can Challenging a Will Hurt Your Inheritance?

Yes, especially if the will includes a “no-contest clause.” This clause states that anyone who challenges the will and loses forfeits their inheritance. However, these clauses aren’t always enforceable, especially if you had reasonable grounds. Always consult with an attorney first.

How to Prevent Your Will from Being Challenged

If you’re writing your own will, you can take steps to make it challenge-proof:

• Follow all state requirements strictly.
• Have disinterested witnesses.
• Use a notary and even record the signing.
• Add a no-contest clause (check state laws).
• Update your will regularly to reflect life changes.
• Store your will securely and register it.

✅ Tip: Register your will with The U.S. Will Registry so your family can find it when the time comes.

Final Thoughts on Challenging a Will

Challenging a will is not just about contesting a document—it’s about defending the integrity of someone’s final wishes. It requires valid legal grounds, strong evidence, and careful timing.

If you believe you’ve been wrongfully excluded or suspect foul play, consult a qualified probate attorney. They can assess your case and help you take the next step.

⚖️ Need help locating a will?
👉 Click here to use The U.S. Will Registry’s Search for a Will Service

 

? FAQ Related to Challenging a Will