How to Choose an Executor of an Estate

Two women discussing how to choose an executor for a will

How to choose an executor is one of the most consequential decisions in estate planning because this individual will assume legal responsibility for administering your estate under probate court supervision. The executor operates as a fiduciary, meaning they must act in the best interests of the estate and its beneficiaries while complying with state law, court procedures, tax obligations, and statutory deadlines. Selecting the right person requires careful evaluation of legal eligibility, financial competence, and personal integrity to ensure your final wishes are carried out accurately and without unnecessary conflict.

Although it may seem like a simple task, this role requires time, organization, and legal responsibility. Therefore, it’s important to choose wisely.

What Does an Executor of an Estate Do?

In learning how to choose an executor, you should first understand the role. An executor’s main job is to carry out the instructions in your will. That includes gathering your assets, protecting property, and ensuring your debts and taxes are paid.

In many cases, the executor must also take your estate through probate. Probate is the court process that validates the will and oversees the estate’s distribution. It can take six to nine months or longer.

Additional responsibilities include:

Notifying banks and creditors of your death
Paying final bills and closing accounts
Filing taxes for the estate
Keeping beneficiaries informed
Distributing assets according to your will

This is not a small task. That’s why you must carefully choose an executor who can manage each duty.

Who Can Serve as Executor?

Before you choose an executor, know your state’s requirements. In most states, an executor must:

Be at least 18 years old (some states require 21)
Be a U.S. resident
Not be legally incapacitated

In some states, a person with a felony conviction may not qualify. Others may bar non-residents unless they appoint a local agent.

Who Can’t Serve as an Executor of an Estate?

Certain individuals are not legally permitted to serve as an executor, depending on state laws and court discretion.

Minors – Anyone under 18 (or 21 in some states) is automatically disqualified.
Non-U.S. Residents – Many states restrict non-residents unless they appoint a local co-executor or registered agent.
Mentally Incapacitated Individuals – A person declared legally incapacitated cannot fulfill executor duties.
Felons – Individuals with felony convictions are often barred due to concerns over integrity and trust.
Parties with Serious Conflicts of Interest – Someone contesting the will or involved in estate disputes may not qualify.
Unqualified Business Entities – Only licensed trust companies may act as executors. Ordinary corporations or LLCs may not.

📌 Note: Always check your state’s probate laws. Requirements and restrictions vary across jurisdictions.

How to Choose an Executor: 5 Key Questions

When you choose an executor, consider the following questions. These will help you select someone capable and reliable.

1. Do they have time?

Managing an estate takes months. The executor must sort paperwork, deal with financial institutions, and respond to legal deadlines. Someone with a demanding schedule may not be the best choice.

2. Are they calm and fair?

Family dynamics can get tense after a loved one’s death. Choose someone who can handle disputes and make impartial decisions.

3. Are they financially responsible?

An executor controls estate funds. You need someone who manages their own money well and understands the importance of accountability.

4. Are they organized?

The job includes paperwork, deadlines, and ongoing communication. A highly organized person is best suited for the role.

5. Do they have legal or financial experience?

It’s not required, but experience helps. If your preferred person lacks this background, they can work with an attorney or accountant.

Why Naming an Alternate Executor Is Essential

Naming an alternate executor is not simply a precaution, it is a necessary safeguard. Life circumstances change. The person you initially appoint may become ill, move out of state, lose capacity, pass before you, or simply decline the responsibility when the time comes. If no alternate is named, the probate court must appoint someone to administer your estate.

When a court selects an executor, that person may not be someone you would have chosen. In some cases, family members may disagree about who should serve, which can delay probate and create tension. By naming an alternate executor, you maintain control over who manages your estate, even if your first choice cannot act.

An alternate also provides continuity. If the primary executor begins administration but later resigns or becomes unable to continue, the successor can step in without requiring additional court intervention. This reduces administrative disruption and prevents unnecessary legal expense.

Ultimately, naming a backup executor protects your estate from uncertainty. It ensures that your instructions are carried out by someone you trust, rather than leaving the decision to a judge.

What If You Don’t Have a Suitable Person?

If no relative or friend seems ideal, you can use a corporate executor. These are banks or trust companies that manage estates for a fee. While they charge a percentage of the estate value, they offer experience and neutrality.

A corporate executor can be a smart option for large estates or when family conflict is expected.

Accepting the Role of Executor: What You Should Know

If someone has chosen you as executor, don’t agree without understanding the responsibility. Ask these questions before you commit:

1. Have we discussed everything?

Have a conversation with the person who chose you. Understand where important documents are stored and what they expect from you.

2. Will I have access to the safe deposit box?

You’ll need legal access to retrieve the will, deeds, or titles. Confirm your authority in advance.

3. Where are valuables stored?

Ask about safes, passwords, and the location of important items. You’ll need this information when distributing assets.

4. Do I know the heirs?

Gather names, contact details, and any helpful notes. You’ll need to locate beneficiaries to notify them and transfer property.

5. Am I comfortable with the will’s instructions?

Read the will carefully. If it’s unclear or complicated, you’ll need time and possibly legal help. If the job feels too big, you can decline.

Choose an Executor Who Will Respect Your Wishes

The person you name will handle everything after you’re gone. That includes finances, family heirlooms, and final decisions. Choose an executor who respects your wishes and values the relationships in your life.

Some people name a close friend or adult child. Others prefer a sibling or spouse. Whoever you choose, make sure they know and agree to serve.

Talk to Your Executor Early

Once you choose an executor, have an open conversation. Explain your intentions. Walk them through your will. Give them access to important documents or a secure location. Let them know where your passwords and account information are stored.

Planning ahead makes things much easier for your loved ones later.

📚 Related Articles

Final Thoughts

When you choose an executor, take your time. The right person will protect your wishes and guide your loved ones.

To make the process easier, start by creating a will. The U.S. Will Registry offers a free online will program developed by experienced estate attorneys.

This user-friendly program walks you through every essential step. It helps you name an executor, list assets, and identify beneficiaries. You can also add guardianship for children and instructions for special belongings.

If you have a simple estate, this tool is ideal. It covers everything you need—at no cost. For those with complex estates or unique family dynamics, it’s smart to begin with the online will. Then, bring it to an attorney to ensure every detail is legally sound.

Creating a will ensures peace of mind. Choosing the right executor ensures your legacy is carried out as you intended.

Start your will today at The U.S. Will Registry. It’s fast, free, and secure.

How to choose an executor of a will?

When deciding how to choose an executor, select someone responsible, organized, and capable of handling financial and legal duties. The person should be trustworthy, impartial, and willing to serve. Consider their availability, communication skills, and ability to manage deadlines, probate procedures, and potential family conflict.

Why is naming an alternate executor important?

Naming an alternate executor protects your estate if your first choice cannot serve. Circumstances change due to illness, relocation, or personal reasons. Without a backup, the probate court may appoint someone you would not have selected, which can delay administration and create unnecessary family tension.

Can a beneficiary serve as executor?

Yes, in most states a beneficiary can serve as executor. Many people name a spouse or adult child who is also inheriting property. However, the person must act in a fiduciary capacity and treat all beneficiaries fairly. Conflicts of interest may arise if disputes develop among heirs.

What happens if no executor is named in a will?

If you fail to name an executor, the probate court will appoint an administrator to manage the estate. This person may not reflect your preferences. Court-appointed administrators must follow statutory procedures, which can increase delays, costs, and the likelihood of disagreements among family members.

Editorial Review:

This article was prepared by estate planning researchers and reviewed by S. Miller and staff. With more than 25 years of experience in estate planning documentation and probate processes, our editorial oversight ensures clarity and accuracy. This content is provided for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.

[View Our Editorial Policy]